“Gimme, Gimme” How to Manage Your Child’s Holiday Gift Expectations

Managing Gift ExpectationsThe holidays are upon us… the season of gifts and “gimme’s.”

All around us, kids are encouraged to reveal their wishes of candy, gingerbread cookies, and overstuffed stockings next to shiny new bikes/game systems/toys-of-the-year, complete with giant bows on top.

Whether for budgets or a desire to live a less cluttered lifestyle, parents everywhere are looking for ways to cut back.

Without spoiling the fun and fantasy of the holidays, how can you reasonably manage their lists this year?

How to Manage Your Child’s Holiday Gift Expectations

  • Good communication is key. Using opportunities daily to teach your values to your children can preserve the excitement of the holidays while keeping realistic expectations. If your children know you don’t approve of violent video games, they won’t be surprised when Santa doesn’t bring one. Be firm and honest with your reasons for not following along with the crowd: “John’s parents make decisions they feel are right for their family, and Daddy and I make decisions we feel are right for our family. While our answer on X is no, we do enjoy saying yes to other things we know you’re wishing for.”
  • Children need to learn how to make choices, prioritize, and deal with disappointment. Consistently giving in to a child’s gimme attitude can morph into selfishness and a sense of entitlement. Children hear they can have anything and everything they want. It’s your job as a parent to clue them into reality. Encourage children to prioritize their wish lists. When they bring you that long list, ask them to choose the top one or two things they really want. If Santa stops at your house, explain to younger children that Santa likes to focus on the gifts they want the most (he DOES have a lot of kids to please, after all!) But don’t ignore the rest of the list. Discuss each item to find out the why’s behind the wishes — understanding why a child wants something can help you find out their true desires, and it’s often not about the “stuff.”
  • Set limits up front about what kids can expect on Christmas morning.  Consider the Want-Need-Wear-Read approach — each kid gets one thing they want, one thing they need, something to wear and something to read. While you can’t control what other people give your kids, you can set the expectation of what they’ll get from you.
  • Emphasize gratitude. Even when children are disappointed, it’s important for them to learn how to be gracious recipients. Expressing gratitude so others’ feelings don’t get hurt is a must-have skill, and it goes beyond the pouty-faced “thank you.” Teaching kids to be genuinely gracious and thankful for all they have can go a long way to helping them understand the concept of “enough,” particularly when there are so many people who don’t have anything.
  • Highlight the rewards of giving. Nothing lifts a child’s disappointment more quickly than giving a heartfelt gift to someone else. Shifting the emphasis from receiving to giving helps children see the exchange of presents from a different perspective. Kids love picking out gifts for other people. In addition to helping kids thoughtfully choose gifts for friends and family, choose a charity, toy drive, food pantry or other group and lend a hand.
  • Make a “family wish list” together and be sure to include non-material wishes—such as taking a walk in the snow or drinking hot cocoa by the fire. These wishes can be granted through “coupons” when it comes time to open gifts, or woven into the weeks surrounding the holidays to extend the celebration beyond one “special” day.
  • Focus on the “magic” of the season — which does not come from lots of toys. Get past the gift grab by making new holiday traditions. Make time for listening to seasonal music, baking treats, making decorations or crafting simple gifts for friends and family. It doesn’t just save money—it makes memories. Focus on activities you can do together as a family, instead of focusing on what gets unwrapped Christmas morning. You’re free to create any tradition you want, so be creative. It could include a walk on Christmas morning, attending a special concert or a lazy day at home. These are the things they remember and talk about year after year — not the toys that were under the tree.


Sign up & receive our free meal planner!

Be the first to receive great, new content — plus get instant access to our weekly meal planner.

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Sandy Kreps

Sandy Kreps

By taking a moderate approach designed to cut over-consumption, live within your means, and make healthy lifestyle choices, Sandy Kreps helps people cut through the chaos of modern life and find a simpler path. She is a contributor to several green living and healthy lifestyle magazines, and she writes regularly on her blog, Modern Simplicity. She's currently working on a new book, “Mommy Simplicity.” In addition to writing, Sandy loves LOLcats, Doctor Who and Pinterest.
Sandy Kreps

Latest posts by Sandy Kreps (see all)


  1. says

    Thank you for this! As a parent who has always had lots of little things under the tree for my son, this year that just isn’t going to be practical. I was wondering how I was going to make this work while preserving that sense of wonder and excitement – this article is full of gems (that want-need-wear-read idea, and the one of making a list of things to do as a family that doesn’t involve ‘stuff’ are brilliant). I’m so grateful!

  2. says

    We do a loose spin on this – 3 wise men, 3 gifts. (Granted Santa does give one as do siblings). Always a mix of practical (clothes) and fun (a toy, book, craft)

    My struggle this year is that we are buying gifts “from the grandparents” as well and we are trying to balance how much that should be.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *